*this post contains affiliate links

The Jeffree Star Blue Blood Palette seems to sell out in a matter of minutes every time that it’s restocked. So if you’ve really been wanting to get your hands on a few of those blues… I gotchu ma!

I had a really hard time finding dupes for Blue Blood because 1. It’s a very unique palette and 2. I don’t have a ton of blue single shadows. It took me three or four attempts and lots of digging but at long last, I found satisfactory dupes for the entire palette! So without further ado…

TOP ROW:

▪︎Cullinan vs Devinah Cosmetics Icing ($5, -20% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- Cullinan is a shimmery white metallic. Icing is nearly identical

Sydney Grace Velvet is also very similar

▪︎Mintea vs Strobe Cosmetics Creep it Real ($6, -10% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- Mintea is a matte mint green. I couldn’t find a dupe for this shade to save my life until Strobe Cosmetics came through and released all of the shades in their Creepy Cute palette as singles. Mintea is a little more blue than Creep it Real but they’re close

ColourPop Checkmate and Sydney Grace Sea Foam are kinda similar but not dupes

▪︎Crystal Flesh vs ColourPop Snake Eyes ($4.50, -10% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- Crystal Flesh is a metallic champagne. Snake Eyes is a touch cooler. Makeup Geek Luna is actually a little closer but it’s double the price

▪︎I’m Cold vs Strobe Cosmetics Cold Shoulder ($6, -10% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- This was another difficult shade but the creepy cute palette saved the day again! Cold Shoulder is a little brighter but they’re pretty damn close

Option 2: Devinah Cosmetics Twink

▪︎Untouchable vs Devinah Cosmetics Promise ($5, -20% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- Untouchable is a light peachy pink with a matte finish. Promise is a little lighter and a little more cool toned

Other options: ColourPop Outta Luck or Lucky You

▪︎Priceless vs ColourPop Hear Me Out ($4.50, -10% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- Priceless is a matte peachy beige. Hear Me Out is lighter

Other options: Sydney Grace Summer Magic, Makeup Geek Beaches and Cream

MIDDLE ROW:

▪︎Power vs Devinah Cosmetics Infamy ($5, -20% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- this one was tough too! Power is a matte slate gray with subtle blue undertones. Infamy is lighter and not as blue. Actually it just occurred to me, that one Melt shadow might be a good dupe. The blue gray matte from the Lovesick stack. I’m not getting off my ass to confirm but I have a strong suspicion

Other options: Sydney Grace Thunderbird, Saucebox Moth

▪︎Blue Blood vs Sydney Grace Oasis ($5, -15% w/ non-affil code BEAUTYCULT)- Blue Blood is a sky blue matte. Oasis is slightly darker

Option 2: Clionadh Cosmetics Tundra

▪︎Deceased vs Devinah Cosmetics Thirst ($5, -20% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- Deceased is an azure blue with a metallic finish. Thirst is a shade or two lighter

Option two: ColourPop Two Piece

▪︎Ice Tray vs Looxi Beauty Atlantis ($5, -10% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- Ice Tray is a soft slate blue metallic. Atlantis is darker

Option 2: Clionadh Cosmetics Sapphire

▪︎Blue Monday vs Blot Beauty Rele ($5)- Blue Monday is an electric periwinkle matte. I was going to use Makeup Geek Indestructible (power pigment) as my dupe even though it’s darker. Then I remembered my Blot Beauty palette (they’re a black owned indie brand based out of Texas) and found Rele. Blue Monday has stronger purple undertones but they’re pretty close.

A third option would be ColourPop Piece of Cake

▪︎Flourishing vs ColourPop Formation ($4.50, -10% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- Flourishing is a vibrant matte teal. Formation is lighter and pulls a bit more blue

The only other dupe that I could find is Makeup Geek Shark Bite but it’s been discontinued

BOTTOM ROW:

▪︎Wealthy vs Sydney Grace Drift ($5, -15% w/ non-affil code BEAUTYCULT)- these are both ivory mattes. Any matte off white would do such as ColourPop Firefly or Makeup Geek Vanilla Bean

▪︎Celebrity Skin vs Makeup Geek Hayride ($6, -10% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- these two are soft brown mattes. They look nearly identical to me. Hayride might be a little darker

Option 2: Looxi Beauty Cream & Sugar

▪︎Entitled vs ColourPop Tiny Tangerines ($4.50, -10% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- Entitled is a metallic teal. It’s a bit more glittery than Tiny Tangerines. Also Entitled pulls a little more blue and Tiny Tangerines a little more green

ColourPop Slay-farer is also similar

▪︎Ocean Ice vs ColourPop Quantum Sleep ($4.50, -10% w/ affil code BEAUTYCULT)- these two are very similar royal blue colors but Ocean Ice is a lot more loosely pressed and has silver glitter

Other options: Sydney Grace JB, Peaches & Cream Sapphire loose pigment

▪︎Cremated vs Sydney Grace Thrilled ($5, -15% w/ non-affil code BEAUTYCULT)- Cremated is a deep blue green matte. It’s slightly more blue than Thrilled

Sydney Grace Woodland is also very similar

▪︎Undertaker vs Sydney Grace Indiana Love ($5, -15% w/ non-affil code BEAUTYCULT)- these two are both navy blue mattes. Undertaker is a little lighter

Sydney Grace Ice Fishing is also similar

Phew! Thank the gods this project is finished! Now to reorganize basically my entire single shadow collection that I tore apart during my hunt for the perfect blues….