MAC SABLE  ($6) vs MAKEUP GEEK LUCKY PENNY ($6)

Earlier this year, MAC lowered the price of their eyeshadow pans from $10 to $6. Which is the same price as MUG eyeshadows so this  isn’t a money saving dupe. Many of you only buy from cruelty free brands or are working towards it (myself included). If that’s the case then MUG LUCKY PENNY is great cruelty free alternative for MAC SABLE. And for everyone else, if you have one then you don’t need the other.

They’re both rosey bronze colors with frost finishes. I’d say that maybe LUCKY PENNY is a hair lighter but they’re virtually the same color, IMO. I prefer the formula of LUCKY PENNY. It’s soft and buttery and I find it to have better color pay off than SABLE.